Thanks to everyone who submitted their comments to the EPA in order to secure a healthy Hudson for current and future generations! We are thrilled to report that EPA received over a thousand comments! Your words will help hold EPA accountable for issuing the only appropriate determination to put the river on a path to recovery!
Scenic Hudson, Riverkeeper, and other partners submitted joint comments urging EPA to find the PCB cleanup to date is not protective of human health and the environment. The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation submitted comments calling for further removal of PCBs from the river.
EPA will be reviewing these comments over several months. By signing up for our mailing list we can keep you up to date with the latest developments! Visit http://www.scenichudson.org/ourwork to sign up.
Technical Key Points
The Hudson River Superfund cleanup has not done the job it was meant to do—secure the health of the river, its wildlife and the people living along it. PCB contamination in the river remains a significant threat to public health and prosperity—as it has for nearly 80 years.
What the experts are saying:
- Following its analysis of the cleanup to date, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration—a sister federal agency—concluded that “Recovery of the Upper and Lower Hudson will not be reached due to elevated PCBs remaining in surface sediment equivalent to a series of Superfund Sites being left behind.”
- At the same time, following its own review of the cleanup’s effectiveness, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation found, “The Remedy is not protective of human health and the environment based on uncontrolled risks, and EPA should undertake all necessary actions to ensure that the remedy becomes fully protective to the benefit of the people of New York State.”
- The review makes clear that PCB levels in the fish and sediment of the Lower Hudson have not benefited at all from upriver dredging. In fact, NYSDEC and the Hudson River Foundation do not expect the dredging to result in additional improvement in the Lower Hudson River.
Business Owners Needed to Take Action
If you own a business in the Hudson Valley, click here to join in a letter to the EPA from the business community.
For over 30 years—from the 1940s to the 1970s—General Electric discharged an unknown amount of PCB-laced waste into the Hudson River from its capacitor manufacturing plants in upstate Hudson Falls and Fort Edward. These toxins have accumulated in the land, river sediment and food web all along the river, turning the Hudson into the largest Superfund site in America—stretching 200 miles to New York Harbor. Scenic Hudson and our partners have fought to get GE to take responsibility for this toxic disaster (with pollution estimated in the billions of pounds) and restore the river and communities along it to their full health.
After six years of dredging, a cleaner, safer Hudson is within reach—but now EPA has allowed GE to dismantle its on-river operation, abandoning the remaining toxic river sediments that federal, state and local agencies warn could set back economic and environmental recovery for decades. Supported by community partners and our dedicated members, Scenic Hudson remains present at every stage of this historic remediation and continues to press for the most comprehensive cleanup possible.
Success and a cleaner, healthier future for the Hudson depends on EPA allowing good science and decisive oversight to direct the actions of the cleanup project before it’s too late.
Scenic Hudson President Ned Sullivan’s Huffington Post blog links poisoned-water disasters in the news with a botched cleanup of toxic Hudson River PCBs. Before the cleanup began the EPA knew there were dramatically more PCBs well beyond “hot spots” targeted for removal, but did nothing to alter its plan. The EPA is failing to protect the environment and our health. Falling short in the Hudson—the country’s largest toxic cleanup—would undercut remediation of health-threatening pollution nationwide. We need to ramp up pressure on the EPA. More than 80 municipalities, 161 state legislators, editorials from The New York Times and numerous valley papers, as well as two federal agencies have called for more dredging. The voice of the people must sound loudly NOW—Submit comments on the Five Year Review to U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Region 2 Director, Gary Klawinski (518) 407-0400 or email@example.com) and tell him that more dredging is needed for the Hudson.
Watch the short film on EPA's Five Year Review Workshop by renowned filmmaker Jon Bowermaster
Watch the mini-documentary by Jon Bowermaster to learn more about the threats posed by the remaining PCBs in the Hudson.
- Campaign for a Cleaner Hudson
- Hudson River Sloop Clearwater
- Natural Resources Defense Council
- News Release: "Flawed Data and Analysis Fatally Undermine EPA’s Findings that Hudson PCB Cleanup Will Protect Environment and Public Health," Sept. 5, 2017
- SUMMARY: Technical Review of EPA Five-Year Review, Sept. 5, 2017
- Take Action Flyer, July 11, 2017
- Take Action Flyer (Spanish), July 11, 2017
- Talking Points for EPA Comments, June 28, 2017
- Take Action Flyer, June 19, 2017
- Take Action Flyer (Spanish), June 19, 2017
- Take Action Flyer, May 2, 2017
- PCB Fact Sheet, May 1, 2017
- PCB Social Media "Meme" for Sharing, May 1, 2017
- Help Needed from Trump, Cuomo to Halt Hudson River Threats, Ned Sullivan, Huffington Post, Jan. 31, 2017
- LETTER: "Submission of Remedial Action Completion Report," GE to EPA, Dec. 23, 2016
- NYSDEC Independent Analysis, Dec. 20, 2016
- News Release: "Scenic Hudson Statement on DEC Review Concluding that PCB Cleanup Fails to Protect Public Health, Environment," Dec. 20, 2016
- News Release: "DEC's Independent Analysis Finds EPA's Hudson River Cleanup Fails to Protect Human Health and the Environment," Dec. 20, 2016
- Letter to EPA from NYSDEC Commissioner Basil Seggos, Dec. 20, 2016
- NYSDEC Independent Report: "Recommendations to EPA for the 'Five Year Review Report' for Hudson River PCBs Site," Dec. 20, 2016
- REPORT: "Hudson River Angler Study," Scenic Hudson and Sierra Club, Dec. 2016
- News Release: "Scenic Hudson Commends Members of Congress for Urging EPA to Continue Hudson River PCB Cleanup," Dec. 14, 2016
- Letter to EPA from New York Congressional Delegation, Dec. 2, 2016
- Letter to EPA from U.S. Rep. Paul Tonko, Dec. 1, 2016
- Letter to EPA from Scenic Hudson and Riverkeeper, Nov. 10, 2016
- REPORT: "Hudson River Fish Advisory Outreach Project, 2009-2016 Project Update," NYS Department of Health, Oct. 2016
- REPORT: Preliminary Results of Hudson River Fish Consumption Surveys, NYS Department of Health, Sept. 2016
- Letter to EPA from U.S. Rep. Chris Gibson, Sept. 28, 2016
- News Release:"Senator Gillibrand Urges EPA to Reverse its Decision to Stop PCB Dredging in the Upper Hudson River," Sept. 20, 2016
- News Release: "Scenic Hudson President Ned Sullivan Hails NYS Attorney General for Challenging GE-EPA Claims that Hudson River PCB Cleanup is Complete," Sept. 19, 2016
- "New York to EPA: Don’t Approve GE’s Cleanup of Hudson," Wall Street Journal, Sept. 16, 2016
- Letter to EPA from New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman asserting that the EPA cannot certify the cleanup as complete, Sept. 16, 2016
- "G.E. Spent Years Cleaning Up the Hudson. Was It Enough?", New York Times, Sept. 8. 2016
- Press Conference: "DEC Challenges Effectiveness of EPA's Remedy for Hudson River Cleanup," Aug. 22, 2016
- News Release: "Scenic Hudson President Ned Sullivan Hails Cuomo Administration for Blowing Whistle on GE-EPA Claims Hudson River Cleanup is a Success," Aug. 22, 2016
- Hillary Clinton statement "Clean Air, Clean Water are Basic Rights," April 4, 2016
- News Release: "Enviros Say EPA Will Leave Hudson Polluted in Rush to Declare Partial PCB Cleanup a Total Success," Feb. 11, 2016
- "Hudson Cleanup far from Complete," op-ed by Ned Sullivan and Aaron Mair, Albany Times Union, Feb. 8, 2016
- "Selling Out the Hudson," New York Times, Oct. 9, 2015
- Letter to Governor Cuomo from 141 Members of the NYS Assembly regarding PCBs in the Hudson River, June 9, 2015
- Letter to Governor Cuomo from 25 NYS Senators regarding PCBs in the Hudson River, June 26, 2015
- Letter to Governor Cuomo from NYS Environmental Leaders regarding PCBs in the Hudson, Oct. 18, 2015
- News Release: "New Report Confirms Fish Injury from Hudson River PCB Contamination," U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, April 23, 2015